September 20, 2023

Is It Better to Pay Off Old Debt or New Debt First?

Learn about debt types, interest rates, financial goals, and strategies to make sound decisions for your financial well-being.

Have you ever wondered whether it is wiser to tackle old debts from the past or focus on clearing out new financial obligations that have recently arisen? It is a financial puzzle that many of us grapple with at some point in our lives. In fact, according to recent statistics, a staggering 80% of Americans carry some form of debt. Whether it is credit card balances, student loans, mortgages, or personal loans, debt has become an integral part of modern living.

The true dilemma, though, is whether you should make old obligations that have been piling up for a while—and may have higher interest rates—priority. Or would it make more sense to focus on debts that are newer and may have lower interest rates but still present a risk to your ability to make ends meet? The solution is more complicated than you might imagine, and choosing wisely might have a big impact on your financial situation.

Let us investigate this money problem in more detail. According to a Federal Reserve survey, the average American household has $8,942 in credit card debt, whereas students have an average student loan debt of $1,183. It becomes evident that many people are faced with difficult financial decisions that call for serious analysis when we take into account the numerous loans and their associated interest rates.

In this article, we explore the factors that influence the decision of whether to pay off old debt or new debt first. By understanding the nuances of different debt types, interest rates, and your financial goals, you can make informed choices and learn how to pay off debt, which sets you on the path to financial freedom. 

So, let's unravel this financial puzzle together, learn about how to pay off credit card debt and discover the best strategies for managing your debt.

Read more: These Budgeting Tips can help you stay on track financially

Is it Better to Pay Off Old Debt or New Debt First?

It's generally wiser to prioritize paying off old debt first. Old debt often carries higher interest rates and can have a more significant impact on your credit score. Focusing on clearing old obligations can help you reduce financial stress and improve your overall financial health.

Deciding Whether to Pay Off Old Debt or New Debt

When determining whether to pay old debt or new debt, follow this checklist:

  • Interest Rates: Compare the interest rates on your old and new debts. Prioritize the debt with the higher interest rate to minimize long-term costs
  • Credit Impact: Consider your credit score. Older debt may have a more significant impact on your credit history. Addressing old debt can improve your creditworthiness
  • Financial Goals: Align your choice with your financial goals. If you're saving for retirement, reduce high-interest debts first to free up funds for investments
  • Tax Implications: Explore potential tax benefits. Some older debts may offer tax deductions or benefits that new debts do not
  • Emergency Fund: Ensure you maintain an emergency fund to cover unexpected expenses while paying down debt
  • Seek Professional Advice: Consult a financial advisor for personalized guidance on your unique financial situation

By evaluating these factors, you can make an informed decision on whether to tackle old or new debt, keeping your long-term financial goals, like retirement savings, in mind.

Understanding the Types of Debt

Before delving into the decision-making process, it is crucial to understand the different types of debt. Debt can be broadly categorized into two main types: secured and unsecured debt.

1. Secured Debt

  • Secured debt is backed by collateral, such as a house or a car
  • If you fail to make payments, the lender can seize the collateral
  • Common examples include mortgage loans and auto loans

2. Unsecured Debt

  • Unsecured debt is not backed by collateral
  • Lenders rely on your creditworthiness to approve these loans
  • Common examples include credit card debt, personal loans, and medical bills[1]

Take Control of Your Finances Today! Sign up for Bright Money and Start Saving Smarter.

Is it better to payoff Old Debt or New Debt First? Bright

Debt Repayment Strategies

Now that we've explored the factors to consider when deciding between old and new debt, let's examine some debt repayment strategies that can help you make an informed decision:

1. Snowball Method: The snowball method is a debt repayment strategy that focuses on paying off your smallest debts first while making minimum payments on larger debts. Once the smallest debt is paid off, you roll the money you were putting towards it into the next smallest debt. This approach can provide a sense of accomplishment as you see smaller debts disappear quickly, which can motivate you to continue the process

2. Avalanche Method: The avalanche method prioritizes paying off debts with the highest interest rates first. This strategy minimizes the overall interest you'll pay over time, potentially saving you a significant amount of money. While it may take longer to see individual debts completely paid off, it is a financially efficient approach

3. Debt Consolidation: Debt consolidation involves taking out a single loan, often at a lower interest rate, to pay off multiple debts. This strategy simplifies your debt by combining it into one monthly payment, making it easier to manage. Be cautious, though, as it does not reduce the actual amount you owe; it just restructures it

4. Debt Management Plan (DMP): A DMP is a formal agreement with a credit counseling agency to repay your debts. The agency negotiates with creditors to lower interest rates and create a manageable repayment plan. You make a single monthly payment to the agency, which then distributes it to your creditors. DMPs can be useful for those struggling to manage multiple debts

5. Balance Transfer: If you have high-interest credit card debt, consider transferring the balances to a credit card with a 0% introductory APR offer. This can give you a temporary reprieve from interest charges, allowing you to pay the principal balance faster. However, be mindful of transfer fees and the introductory period's duration

6. Debt Settlement: Debt settlement involves negotiating with creditors to pay less than the total amount owed, typically in a lump sum. This approach can significantly reduce your debt, but it can also damage your credit score and lead to tax consequences. It should be considered a last resort

7. Increase Income: Another way to accelerate debt repayment is to increase your income. This could involve taking on a part-time job, freelancing, or selling unused items. The extra income can be applied directly to your debts, helping you pay them off more quickly

8. Cut Expenses: Reducing your expenses can free up more money for debt repayment. Create a budget, identify areas where you can cut back, and redirect those savings toward your debt. It might mean making temporary sacrifices for long-term financial gain

9. Emergency Fund First: Before aggressively paying down debt, consider building an emergency fund. Having savings to cover unexpected expenses can prevent you from relying on credit cards or loans when financial emergencies arise, ultimately helping you avoid further debt

10. Automate Payments: Set up automatic payments for your debts to ensure you never miss a due date. This can help you avoid late fees and maintain a positive credit history

11. Bi-weekly payments: Instead of making monthly payments, consider making half of your monthly payments every two weeks. This results in 26 half-payments, which is equivalent to 13 full payments per year. Over time, this extra payment can significantly reduce your debt

12. Financial Counseling: Seek advice from a financial counselor or advisor who can provide personalized guidance based on your unique financial situation. They can help you develop a customized debt repayment plan and provide strategies for long-term financial stability

13. Stay Motivated: Debt repayment can be a long and challenging journey. Stay motivated by tracking your progress, setting milestones, and celebrating small victories along the way. Visualize the financial freedom you'll gain as you reduce your debt

14. Avoid Accruing New Debt: While repaying your existing debt, avoid taking on new debt whenever possible. This includes being cautious with credit card usage and avoiding unnecessary loans

15. Debt Snowflake: The debt snowflake method involves making small, additional payments whenever you can. For example, if you have some spare change or a few dollars left in your budget, apply it directly to your debt. Over time, these small contributions can add up [2][3][4]

Start Your Journey to Financial Well-Being. Sign up for Bright Money and Transform Your Finances.

Now that we've established the types of debt,

let's dive into the factors to consider when deciding whether to pay off old debt or new debt first.

Factors to Consider

When deciding whether to pay off old debt or new debt first, there are several crucial factors to consider. Each factor plays a role in shaping your debt repayment strategy and can help you make informed decisions. Here are the key factors to take into account:

1. Interest Rates

One of the most critical factors to consider when deciding which debt to pay off first is the interest rate. Interest is the cost of borrowing money, and it can significantly affect the overall cost of your debt. In general, you should prioritize paying off debt with the highest interest rate first, regardless of whether it is an old or new debt.

  • Old Debt: If you have older debts with high interest rates, they are likely costing you more in interest charges over time. Paying off old debt with high interest rates can save you money in the long run
  • New Debt: New debt may have lower interest rates, especially if you have recently taken out a loan or opened a new credit card account. While it is essential to stay current on your new debt obligations, consider paying off high-interest old debt concurrently[2][3][4]

2. Debt Types

The type of debt you have matters when deciding which to pay off first. Secured debts, such as mortgage loans and auto loans, typically have lower interest rates compared to unsecured debts like credit card debt.

  • Old Debt: If you have old secured debt with a low interest rate, it may be less urgent to pay it off quickly. You may have the option to make minimum payments while focusing on high-interest unsecured debts
  • New Debt: Paying off new secured debt is crucial to protect your assets. Falling behind on mortgage or auto loan payments can lead to foreclosure or repossession. Ensure you prioritize these obligations while managing unsecured debts[2][3][4]

3. Financial Goals

Your short-term and long-term financial goals can influence your decision regarding old versus new debt. Consider the following aspects:

  • Old Debt: If you have old debts that are close to being paid off and you're nearing a financial milestone like retirement or buying a home, it might make sense to focus on clearing those old debts to free up your financial resources for your upcoming goals
  • New Debt: On the other hand, if you have recently taken on new debt for an essential purpose, such as education or home improvement, you may need to prioritize paying off this new debt to ensure you can achieve your financial objectives[2][3][4]

Ready to Achieve Financial Freedom? Join Bright Money Now and Supercharge Your Savings.

4. Credit Score and Creditors

Your credit score is a crucial factor that can be impacted by your debt management decisions. Late or missed payments on either old or new debt can harm your credit score. Consider the following:

  • Old Debt: If you have old debts with delinquent or late payment history, addressing these issues can help improve your credit score over time. Creditors may be willing to negotiate settlements or payment plans for old debts
  • New Debt: Maintaining timely payments on new debt is essential for preserving and potentially improving your credit score. A good credit score can open doors to lower interest rates and better financial opportunities[2][3][4]

5. Tax Considerations

In some cases, the tax implications of your debt may influence your decision. Mortgage interest, for example, may be tax-deductible in some situations, potentially reducing the effective interest rate on your home loan. Consult with a tax professional to understand how your debt may affect your tax liability.

  • Old Debt: Some older debts may have tax consequences if they are forgiven or settled. Be aware of potential tax liabilities when negotiating old debts with creditors
  • New Debt: New debt may have specific tax advantages or disadvantages depending on the type of debt and its intended use. Understanding the tax implications can inform your repayment strategy[2][3][4]

6. Legal Obligations

Certain types of debt, such as child support or court-ordered judgments, come with legal obligations and consequences for non-payment. These legal obligations should take precedence over other debts, whether old or new.

  • Old Debt: If you have old debts with legal obligations, it is essential to address them promptly to avoid legal consequences, including wage garnishment or property liens
  • New Debt: Ensure you prioritize legal obligations associated with any new debt you may have incurred. Failure to meet these obligations can have serious legal repercussions[2][3][4]

7. Emotional and Psychological Factors

Debt can take a toll on your emotional and psychological well-being. The stress and anxiety associated with debt can impact your overall quality of life. It is essential to consider how different debt repayment strategies affect your mental health.

  • Old Debt: Paying off old debt can provide a sense of accomplishment and relief, especially if you've been carrying it for a long time. Eliminating older debts may give you peace of mind and reduce financial stress
  • New Debt: Managing new debt responsibly from the start can help you avoid the emotional distress that often comes with mounting debt. Setting a budget and creating a plan to pay off new debt can provide a sense of control and security[2][3][4]

Read more: Debunking Common Credit Myths: What Really Affects Your Credit Score?

Don't Miss Out on Financial Wellness. Sign up for Bright Money to Unlock a Brighter Financial Future.


Deciding whether to pay off old debt or new debt first is not a one-size-fits-all proposition. It requires careful consideration of various factors, including interest rates, financial goals, credit score, and emotional well-being. While prioritizing high-interest debt is generally advisable, your unique circumstances may necessitate a tailored approach.

Ultimately, the goal is to regain control of your finances, reduce debt, and work toward a debt-free future. Whichever strategy you choose, consistency and discipline are key to achieving your financial objectives. Regularly review your financial situation, adjust your repayment plan as needed, and seek professional guidance when necessary. 

By taking proactive steps to manage your debt, you can pave the way to a more secure and financially stable future.

Join Thousands of Smart Savers. Sign up for Bright Money and Ensure Your Financial Stability Today.




Q. Can I prioritize paying off my older debts even if they have lower interest rates?

Yes, you can choose to pay off older debts with lower interest rates if it aligns with your financial goals and provides peace of mind. While paying high-interest debts first is generally recommended, prioritizing older debts may make sense if you want to clear your financial slate or reduce the number of creditors you owe.

Q. How does paying off old debt affect my credit score?

Paying off old debt can have a positive impact on your credit score by reducing your overall debt load and demonstrating responsible financial behavior. However, the specific effect on your score may vary based on your credit history and the type of debt you're paying off. In most cases, it is a step in the right direction for improving your creditworthiness.

Q. What are the potential tax implications of settling old debts?

Settling old debts, especially if the creditor agrees to forgive a portion of the debt, can have tax consequences. The forgiven amount may be considered taxable income, potentially increasing your tax liability. It is advisable to consult with a tax professional to understand the tax implications and plan accordingly.

Q. Can I use a debt consolidation loan to manage both old and new debts?

Yes, debt consolidation is a strategy that can be applied to both old and new debts. By consolidating multiple debts into a single, lower-interest loan or credit account, you can simplify debt management and potentially reduce overall interest costs. However, the effectiveness of debt consolidation depends on the terms of the new loan and your ability to make consistent payments.

Q. How can I find a reputable credit counselor or debt management agency for assistance?

To find a reputable credit counselor or debt management agency, start by checking with organizations like the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) or the Financial Counseling Association of America (FCAA). These organizations can provide a list of accredited agencies in your area. Additionally, read reviews, ask for recommendations from trusted sources, and ensure the agency you choose is accredited and transparent about its fees and services.

Get the Bright App
AI Powered App, to Delete Debt

Get financial tips delivered to your inbox every week!

Subscribe to stay up-to-date on exclusive stories from Bright.
Reach out and request help as required.
Enter e-mail id
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Please enter a valid email